Author(s):
Title:
I. Information for the Editorial Board
- Suitability for this journal:
-
the paper is appropriate for this journal (yes/no)
-
if no, then what alternate journals may be suggested to the authors for
consideration?
-
Originality and significance of results (yes/no/others):
- results are original
- results are of scientific significance
- results are of practical significance
- Journalistic criteria (yes/no/others):
- abstract is informative enough
- paper is clearly written
- length relative to substance is adequate
- aim of the paper is clearly stated
- paper is placed in proper context with relative works
- mathematical deviations are adequately detailed
- paper is adequately referenced
- all figures and tables are necessary
- paper is free of technical and other errors
- mathematical and experimental results are rigor
- results and conclusions are justified enough
- Recommendations (yes/no)
- paper may be accepted as submitted
- paper requires revision and re-review
- paper should be declined
- paper should be passed to another referee
- Private comments to the Editorial Board
II. Remarks and recommendations for the authors
|