: http://groups.google.com/group/sci.physics.researc...;
:
: Newsgroups: sci.physics.research
: From: Perspicacious <iperspicaci...@yahoo.com>
: Date: Thu, 4 Aug 2005 00:56:49 +0000 (UTC)
: Local: Thurs, Aug 4 2005 4:56 am
: Subject: Why isn't the mathematician Henri Poincaré acknowledged as the true discoverer of special relativity?
:
: Why isn't the mathematician Henri Poincaré
: acknowledged as the true discoverer of the
: special theory of relativity?
:
:
: http://www-cosmosaf.iap.fr/Poincare-RR3A.htm
:
:
: http://arxiv.org/abs/physics/0408077
:
: Physics, abstract
: physics/0408077
: From: Filimonova Irina V. [view email]
: Date (revised v4): Wed, 6 Jul 2005 09:20:06 GMT (138kb)
:
: Henri Poincare and Relativity Theory
: Authors: A. A. Logunov
: Comments: 253 pages
: Subj-class: General Physics; History of Physics
:
: The book presents ideas by H. Poincare and H. Minkowski according to those the essence and the main content of the relativity theory are the following: the space and time form a unique four-dimensional continuum supplied by the pseudo-Euclidean geometry. All physical processes take place just in this four-dimensional space. Comments to works and quotations related to this subject by L. de Broglie, P.A.M. Dirac, A. Einstein, V.L. Ginzburg, S. Goldberg, P. Langevin, H.A. Lorentz, L.I. Mandel'stam, H. Minkowski, A. Pais, W. Pauli, M. Planck, A. Sommerfeld and H. Weyl are given in the book. It is also shown that the special theory of relativity has been created not by A. Einstein only but even to a greater extent by H. Poincare. The book is designed for scientific workers, post-graduates and upper-year students majoring in theoretical physics.
Чего только не найдешь по поиску в Интернете!
Вот, к примеру
"Prof. Winterberg has demonstrated that even in their mutilated state these printer's proofs show that Hilbert had the generally covariant field equations of gravitation, before Einstein. This constitutes positive proof of Einstein's plagiarism, because we have a letter from Einstein to Hilbert dated 18 November 1915 in which Einstein acknowledges receipt of a copy of Hilbert's manuscript, which Einstein had requested from Hilbert on 15 November 1915. The chronology is straightforward. Einstein received a copy of Hilbert's work on 18 November 1915. Hilbert delivered his lecture to the Goettingen Academy on 20 November 1915. Einstein betrayed Hilbert's trust and plagiarized Hilbert's work on 25 November 1915."
http://home.comcast.net/~xtxinc/Response.htm
А еще по Западу гуляет версия, что это как раз Гильберт дал Эйнштейну материал по теории относительности, чтобы насолить своему давнему оппоненту Пуанкаре. Эйнштейн испугался последствий и первую статью послал от имени своей жены Амелии Эйнштейн.
После публикации рукопись загадочным образом испарилась, а жена довольствовалась обещанием денежной части первой же нобелевской премии.
Кстати, получила-таки.
Слухов много, чему верить неизвестно, да и стоит ли... верить чему-то? |
» Альтернативный форум