. : http://www.adass.org/adass/proceedings/adass98/reprints/whiterl.pdf
: Fri Jul 16 22:18:57 1999
: Tue Oct 2 14:37:50 2012
: IBM-866

:
j| hy a Gx Q h a @x a sv s cx $ t # '| vu ) Gs u w D q av 1 4 G Gs u o Gw u s s X s a Qx Q
)S DR Q

)W )W DW Q

sv s x
VU

u
T

av ?

$ s
I

f Xs h
0

X y
B

q s X av s v D Xw av h Q s c a y w h
7

Q X w w s
6

D

X v s s? { s 6 q hy Q o? P h

c w Gw u b u


av

n




a x as h q av a h a Px s b hu q y Q q $ s Xw v s as b hu Q f ' w ts w w y hw x Q P as | G as ' w cs X 3 h q av { x s as a h Xx s b u q av x hy q hy G q a x G| h Q X f s ' Xw av ? A a " h Gs u A a @ s aw ' Xw Gx q y Q s x Gx G A @9 G| s as ' w x X y X av G s as h a Xx s b nu Q a s & z ? t j? 8 G| x Q b u 3w s as a h a Px s b fu b Pu X y Xx y X s q av | aw ' Xw y hy Q a h a Xx s b Xu X q av { y hw x Q $y X s q av f Xy w aw ' Xw y q av o a h a Px s b hu q Dy Py s sw Pw Q a Gx hy Q hw as a h a ss s w q v t a h a Px fw Q Px s b Q h X av n x X av ?} t| v hs s b P x u av D Q hy Q & u X D X s P q| av P ' av o} a h b c | aw x G| h Q Gu u a s Xs a G u as s c a qx w ' Xw Iu hu a hs ' Gw ' w a b Q s 6 % av D aw ' x B f x Xs y Xw av Gx Q b 6u Q Xw y 6 hy ' u ) as 4 q Q X w s av a Xw h Gs Xw hy Q Xy x

s as 3 & P y h w y

q hw 'w c hy ' w

s v @ Gx t qx P j x q av a Xx b 3 G ? t as h X a x Q

j? av #

' w f a H a? Ps s b #u Gx Q 54 P ' 8 6 as

s X 4 H v Xu s v u 'x w a ss q X sv 32 R 1! w s 'w Xw av # q v



Xs B? # v G 6 x t q h v ? '? w X aw ' w Qx ' u w

)! h H " q av nv A A? ) w a 3 Gx Q a

$y 1 6F a h x w as ( s D " t x

av ts a Gx P G h? ? X s q av s E D% a a s Q b hu Q G aw Q P ' &% ! q av av " Q h R w a 'x hs aw ' hy Q a h Q X f b u $ s D h G

q &y q v? s ? &

w 'x v au

u n X x B h a w n

P ' w x s " #w x Xs v G ? hy Xx s b u a x Q s

h q Dy f a u 'x cw Q a h Q s Q c hy Q a

Gx v 'x h b hu q Q h a s b Xu X Q h Q ts h s b

aw a v Xx q T h Xx

I q Xw y c s w

w a Gx Xw y a Xx hs ts ' w q {y Q

q av hy Q s 6 $ Xs x $

| ' w ~w hy Q ' Gw u v? ? ( o @ q ? s a h a Xx b hu ) C ! a h a Px u Gw u s s q Qx a b Xu X y a ? Q $# h? '? R ? as as G s 3 X % ' w 'x 6w u ? '? ? j? G % $ f h Xx b Xu b q x as X v ' x x qx h t a u a n B s 3 y Xy av G| q sw s (! ? s b s a Xx "! ? v ? s b # s q av s s # h w s a t

c ? ? $ s P %w av 8

6 A o t A v h s a a n av ' v ts P 'w $ s b u w s P s hy Q s Xy as a as a s Iv X c tw ' Gw u s P h a Px h a Px q $ s ' w Xs av Dy I w Pw q av as G

u as

a h

Q Gx q Q Pw Gx

Q Gw u v Xw ss s G

Gu w

s b s | h b ' as Xs Q " $

u s ' w u q Xy s a

Gx

| h P P ' w s b u s b u | q as X Qx Q w s q h s as ' sw 6 y w h a Xx

8 s h aw ' t tw Q q q Xy s

Xw s av ' q Gx c b

8w h s 'x h q xr s a s Q ' w x X av h x Q b @ | P fs h Xy t h a Xx P { hy av @x s a D u Q

w Xx v u n x 1 c s u 3w ' aw Q h 8w w s w Q X {

s h a Xw av a s h Pw h 'x Xw a Q w av X t Q h c

X v a ' x b Xu q qw a Px ' ' Xw b %u x a " h h G

1 t Gx G| 6 G 'x Pw a X a Q v u Q ' w Ps { ss X {s s ' u as ' w h Xx h Xw

X av Q Q h t h qs t X q v s X v aw ' v

s as w Qx q hy q Gx { h Px X x av s X q qw au w y G a o I q Q f Pw h X

s q h a Px a h b Gu { ' av s hy Q Q s w qw s b hu c X Xy Xw hy Q h ss c Ps X v hu

Xy G s b u w w s Gx c hy a hy a x b as a h a G Q P h ' q as Q "

Xu $ hu q c { t a x h a h Q Q P Px P P ' sw

s Q y t 8 q a Xx ss s a Px P w

P s P q av x s b q q w s Xw Xs ~v

t Gs u Gw u r Q 'x w s s G b hu G a q

as a s b h q av Xy h @ s fu c aw ' Xw y q % ts hv as a h }

c h " v au @ Q " Q q as y $ Gw s q ' o} Xx

c w Xs $ s s Q G Gw hy Q a 6u ) av ts Xw av h| s s X

y X s q s q av f q y q av } D h ' a Xx h Gs $ h h ' h P b tu G 1

as ' w s au ) 6s w a aw ' Pw

$ s Px y

' T a ' B 3 ) ' 1 G D B 3 b ' q v s A X 8 R q 3 3 b q 6 G h v q b b G 6 s s y h P h G a x q ax Gx 1 X Q Xs ~v X} T| {z y 'x Pw v u ts r P j cd i A qp ok R & n bm cl Td 4 vk ji R hg fe #d R ' ' P s # & & P T y

xU 9 t7 S 4 4 R7 bw t "p #U " U 8! 9 v 4S B7 A u t "F 6U sr TU qp RS 4 G7 hi ) R h g f7 "e fU "e U ! d bd d cW bS a` GY XW VU A TC S 4 $7 4 4 7 #0 R7 4 7 4 Q7 Q2 P IH GF 0 E E E DC 4 B7 A( @0 '9 8 7 6 5 4 32 10 ) ( ' & % $ # "!


y 3y f w wg & D l r Hh j nm wg D 8 ( h j e H D e 8 ( h t & ? )p t u ? ( h ? & D ( u w |f )y x &f 8 &e c e H w f d 8 x 3 ( & e eu ) e h w ) Y j x g Dh @ & D 6 j eu ) i ? )p De j )m e P e 3 )u 8 ) e @ D` X e ) w j | D ) 3 8 )p C & 8 & v w ( 6u 8 ) )g w f d )p H ( ) e h & 8 w &f d jg (y )y eu ) D ) ( ) h 8f D j r{ D u He w f d j f e r{ & 3m i f j m f j 1m & ) 8 &u H e h X 5 e h He w |f ? d s{ ( h d |? d He w f

Du d 3 e { 3 wg 3 ) 3 8 De x e &e p ( { ( e h ) e h j 1 k ? ? Hh ( H{ e D He w Df ( u $ H g e ) x 3 e uu X & D l p

w f d & 3 d

j H ( w &f C s w &f C ( h u

wy e H j 3 d ) u w ) | w j & X p )p g 6 m ( h 3 e h 5 ~? r Y 8 )p i & H |

Df d 7 ? & D l



( D e 8 5 6 5m Du d 3 D w ef e{ u e @ ( h x

e & D x

He w rf wg d ) |p ) D X

ee h & ) ) j ) s

wy D ( &{ ) 3 p

w ) w d & s w j p &

ee h j ) ) j ) j ~ k &e e w d

y D l ? j m ) D w ef & n & & y D ) w j )y & H ( ? ? ( &{ ) 3 D ) & H 8 ( h u w ( h He w @f Du d 3 w ) w d r & e & ) D w ef D j e u 3 H w x 1 g e h d 8 q Du d D e x g j & ) r{ & n D ) w & )p p )p ' s d & H ( j 3m 3 x j ~ um )p p w tm ( h x He j x ( h o e h ) ( 3 C i )p

j w Df j u

e { e D &

H j 3 D & ) e 6{ | ee 6{

( & G &p w Df 1 ( 1 ( h se D x 3 d ~ k 3 ) ( D ) 3 j H ( & Du d D d | D w wf )f e )p e h e e h e h De e h & ~ D ) w &

H & 3 D j ) r{ & D ) w j ) 3 & C

w )f ( w{ wf )f ee h & ) ) j ) | D ( h (g w w ( { ) 7 p & ( h w &f 5

Du lk w Df d g d w d { ( r 8 5e Y e p ( h

H j 3 D j r ) e 6{

H & 3 3 w d w ef D w l e su 8 e e & e u{ 5 w ) r H i ) x 3 e

Dy w j & ( H{ p H j 3 ( { 8 p 5y wy & D l p ) $ &e y X wg D ) 3 8 D e 8 & H ( & H ( ) ( ) C ' | j e H | He w Df ( u He ( eu ) x w Df j e pu &e d D 8 ) 8 te ) G up ) j D w wf ef {

w Df d 8

( & e & & w gf 7 8 d ( { H d 3m d & H ( i ( h 5 3 H u &f ) ~ sm )y 3 D w Df ( Du lk w Df d x

( e s{ ) & Du x

)f m & ) sp & i y d $ 3 ( h o

d ( &{ H 3m x ( 3 3 e h i H Y 5y "

) & e Du x

D w ef D w l e u Du jm w f D e su d ) C

e h n )p p h )f D w d d i )p ( h 5

j e { )m i 3 e h p 6 um j )p ) & m ( H )y x &e

" j D 6m & ) w ( u He w f e h d &f 8

w d d & D ) w j s " C

e h j ) ) j )

D ( &{ ) 3 e D l i

w ) w d r & ( h

j D & H j 3 D e & & e d d 3 8

)y d & H ( 5 w ) w d

H j w )f p & n ~ w d d @ &e ( h }

e & D j r ) e r{ |

D ( &{ ) 3 e D l u )y ) 3 8

" X ) w f &e | eu ) i ( h

ee h j ) ) j ) 3 e h &u H ) " ) e h 3 d

w e h 7 g

h )f D o

H w )f He G sp &e eu ) e ( h ( h 8

) e ) e h f & e { D Du d D x

3 h s ) w Pf He w pf

w &f d w d w )f 3 e h f e h C e Dg 8 & " C d De j )m

eu H d D )y ) 3 8 & q )e e ( u w Df 7 1 m C " j & ) | Du w ( & h

) j e 3 e )u ~ j D ( xh D 6 j P ) x ce " d & ) ( e H

j & ) 3 d t D ( h ) 3 8 )y ) 3 8

H & 3 D j ) r{ h &f e h ( h D w wf )f r D w 1 j e cu u ) P

j )g j & ) &

H j 3 D j r ) e r{ n ) )m j H ( { ) 7

wg D ) ( ) e h f "

g D l )p D e x

) x He w f

3 ~

3 e Pu

w j r ) e r{ ~ t

r " 6 ~ x

~ " D 6 7 n

y r 7 ) D X P d j e h 6 )Y ) D X d e { De ( h f e D ( ) d 3 n E wy D 6 l ~ g ) 8 e d H o &e & D h &f e h & 3 e u e | 3 ( )g d j e h d H ( r ) 8 e ( h r 6 i )p 6 e ( ( 7 ) 3 ) D x ) G xp ) j & e 6u e h w x h )f D H ~ e ) dp e ) d w j D ) D i ) wp w ( h u e H{ ( h P u e H{ ( h ( & 8 jg (y )y wg D d 3 e & ( h )g j r D ( eu D w ( u & D 6 j '

) 7 & w f w o e



Du d ) ~ m d 3 w ) ) e m He e h &

D w )f 7 )u wy w d 8

e H & 3 & D ) w f g 1 @ e ( h H @ ( h ( 1 o ( & 5 He G p 3 @

w ef e{ u d r & j 3m w ) w Df p 6 3 1 ( h 5 d & H e

H j 3 D j r ) e r{ ( h ' d t{ ( h ( h ( h e ) e h 5

( ) n @

H j 3 D j r ) e 6{ ) ( 8 y 3 e 5u

w j & )

D ( { 3 D ( ~f lk r D j w f e h Du e & 8 d C q

H ) g r ) 3 5u m t ( r e ~ o

wy D H 1 ( { j r ) w ~f lk H j 8 H j 3 D j r ) e r{ $ He G p H 7 3 w j w Df j e u ( ) q

d ) D w f & 7 ( H w & e h x H & 3 D

D 3 g " " 6 g w d w 8 x He d )e 3 $ g d i d D ( h @ qe & 3 D ( @

e w d w ( 5u

&u H{ ( h s

l ) r{ wy D ( &{ ) 3 ( H{ p )p o

d 3 & e ) e 3 t r & H e & 3 H

g r

D ( 3 He e eu ) | 3 p

w H j 3 w ( &u e H w f ) e H j j eu )u e & D j r ) e r{ 3 5 d 8 u ) v &e ) w &f 8 e eu H d D ) w Cf He ( eu ) t He e H d d ) & H j ~ }m ( & H w oz )y j jm D e x d ) D & i He w f & s j & ) & r D d D s

e )u D j )p | ) ( 3 H i

& r ) 8

j nm ) w 1f lk e H j

e h ) wg D ) 3 8

( & 3 H & )

r vy 1h ex vq wh vh ut

cs

r 3q pi

gh gf ed cb

a

)` DY X


p

qu

0 w

r Wd mu C @f

4 f 0r r

u p i w V 0f 4

w

r

ju G 4g r uf 0f f p C Wd

s g s C r C

uf w y Y g u Wd 0 Y h

u

r r C

f 0 r p X W

i 4 Sf 0 wr r x w 2i 6r q f x hg 0f w

d 0 p p C r

0 hr d 0i rx r } u u

6s r 8 # qp 0 r

C d Y u f x 4 f %k G s hg U 0 I i u g sf } 0

0 8 h f e r g Y Y u p C 'd

f i r 4 4f r C

0r } qu r W r i

qu Cs Q p d 4i w

C f s Wd 0f

d d i x | r 2i 0r q ' p yu

mf i k i r jr 4 iu s Yw 0 u w

0r

p r x w s Ts 0 u qu ju I

2f

i i u ju f k

W r u 2r p r u f ut f| r h f Y v hg u ' U p W Tr r x y jr 4 f k g hr 4 p x r q f r 2f p d 0 6 0 f f R 'd i y

U

hg @f

h f G i r 0 d Y f i Q u Cs r s Y u f C A W 6r q f x o f fk

f C s h f G f |

r 0 p jr 'r e i 0 C

#r r s k fu r 0 Wd r } qu f Wd jr Wd jr 0 W r f d



ju p Y W 6 r jr w p

t W r 4 i 0r p 8x

W U p g r w r s sf W r g S Yw u

r h sr Y C I 8 w f k r 0

Y h W r 4g f w 2i s f ~ U s g f jr v

4 0f W Cx

r sf 4g

p G G f u qp f qu W r 8 r Yw Wd r C p Wd g



f G Y 0 Wd hr 6 4 f @ Y u p 8x r 0

W 0r r u r p Au

qp i 0 I r 0 0r p

Wd r u g ju

6 u p Y u f 8 w f 4 m

x C f 0 Y

4 2f d u 0f

Yf hg 2 W

h g p g pf p s 0r p

S qr d ur yx Yw

0 r 0 0 m u

C f yk r

d d g 0 Y 0

f uf

4 p W C 0r

4f ju qr h Gu

4i f G qu

0r p p m

g f m Y u ( W 6r q i h W r 0f

h f

u f ju d }

f f C qp e f r hg @f e w 0f 2i p Wd r s 4g f 8 i W 0 i u 2f f u u r s Y u gx 2 W 0r x G u p h f p

e S| p hp 0f S 0 yx 0r r (r

8 8 p Wd qr 2 x p 0r 0w r q s u r 0r p Th Yw p (r 'k w r

qu h r r d d Y 4 f f Yw p Au p r yx k u f i

k m Yw ~h 4f r d 0

8u w Wd U r 0 G i V 2i p r } r 0 r | u g x ' i Y u p i 0 0g p w I m h r r Y

u q r 0 u W

Y u r 0 % C 0 C } 4f 0 s r W r

6 d 0 0 g 8

i d 0r Qp Wd 2f w C s p ru p h hp q ju C C r (u g g w

' 0r 0 k r f f G

ru 0 W r 8 hp f (u

d Y 0 f qu r 0 u 2 u Y 0r p ~ yk 0 r g f Gh xg

Wd C W jr p r r i x Y 0f 0 h 2 p C C r u jr 0 k 0 f C

jr h f 2 p u 0f } mf I w xV t u W 0r Q 'd 0r W 0r C Y u

r 6s p p 8x d s

k @ p i d qp i E y Y u e f C Yw 4f 6 S 0 C r Yw r pu

u 0 e

T g g

W S g r s d C 8 p 0 0r



Y

C g i ! T hr 0r 0 $ w r p f r qp e y yk } f i C

p u V kn g

s Y u f C h f G i r s Cx r hr Ck 0 r 0 m r G Th k Wd jr 0 W 0r p 8x Yw u r s hr Ck 0 r 0 $ u } u p 2 s W 4r Ck 0 S h p g f k R e f 0 g ~h ju m r 0 Yf hg 2f G hr l Y f pu x i u r 4 f (u Ck d 0 2 4 r Yw f 8f r x qr u p 8 r} S| h 2f 8d r $ jr 4 8 hr 4 0f u f qu e 8 hr p ju r Wd jr e 0 m 2 W Wd xf 0r p yx 0r 0 W Y u f Yw 0r p yx

8 w i u f h 0p p }up C md Wd Yw yl x W r 0

y y 0 jr 0 W

g 0 f 2r p

2f 0 W 0r p yx 8k T{ %z u r 0 Yw u

u r r r

r xw i g 8 w If W r w

Y f hr Wd r Yw u r g 2 f

uf g } yx s hr f 0 m r 2

d hr Ck f T r 0 wf 4 r Gx ih Y u 0f

pf u f Y p 0 W

Wd 0r p ju #f p ju # f u x g d u Cv U ut u e s r 0r p 8x Yw

0r r g 8 r x f C Y } u s g 8 w u 0

p Wd 0r p wf ( u W r p ru 8f r W hr 0

2 p ju ju s i qx % 6 W 6r q f k } qu W Tr hq f 0 v 0 u

f #f Q xo x po u 0r pu

p r r w p x

Y u f C h f G i u
8

Y u f i c

`

s W r g 8 w f G f (u x g f C Y u p Au Y u 2f 0 W 0r p yx Yw vu t Cs U 0r qp Yi hg @f e
0 0 Compressed Size (bits/pixel) 10 15 5

b

YX WV U

) T !5 SB R QP D 43 %1 I H GF 65 43 E1 6D CB A @9 87 65 43 21 0) ) ('& % $ #" !

Simulated 1-D FIRST 4C 31.30 WFPC2 Omega Cen STIS MAMA echelle

2 4 6 B (noise bits in quantization)

a

d




m ! 1 # } h p H } } h } 1 m } h ! } } 9 p H h p 9 p $ ~ h { }7 m v ? 6x c7 2& 1 0 C u 1 0 C 6( %d 2 $ " ) 0 ) %5 13 p %0 0 ( 8 8( 6) u0 !& 8 G
%3

x x x

1 % 1 D0 & ( A ! 1~ 8 ( A 0 1~ 8 ( A

~ 9 3 j & 8 8( w) p& 80 D) & 0 A r Xv p5 9 % 5 t 13 %" 0 6( d l %) 0 ( Y h %@ ~ 1 ! $ T~ W 4 8( ( ~ Rv G E & A q % 3 3 ~ 6d d 8 ( G G # ~ m7 2A !" r $ 6" ~ 1 ! 6 3 0 ~ m" 0 G Rv G % ~ ) " 0 C t0 8 ( ( 0 ( 6) %" 2 u & ~ u 7 H T }7 7 p R p ~ c7 & 0 R A ( A ( C 0 m" 0 G q % ~ 1 ! Q x

1 ! ( C !~

H } } T 1 h 9 R v h ! h v } h ~ 5 8 ( u & 80 1( 0 A ( s pd u q ~ 1 ! ( !~ 5 1~ 3 !) 03 p
" 1d 0 q %3 3 ~ $0 2" !) 3 x 6 0 8 8( ) $ "



r B ~ r 13 ~ 13 d ) 0 ~

v } ~ & 8( ) 0 " 0 6( d 2" ) %" 0 ( 7 ~ !A


) 5 1 2 ~ E 5 G 0 q G s ~

0 ( # d ? 1~ $ %"

9o Hf m }f | {f z f y q %0 8( !) 8 t( % $ 6"
8( %) 0 2) ) %) A 1 0 C

h 10 t " 5

px " 2 G wv 80 u( m) t

A sr

1q po n m lf k ji h gf ed

7 !" s 8d )
Pixel



8 $( !" s 8d ) 4 0 9( F I C @0 " 6& 2 8 ( c h @ ? r? ( 8 ( 3 & 0 ) C @0 %0 0 ( 4 13 3 ud & 6 x r?
-2 0

" x
-2 0

w

w

$ 6" ! s r PI 1 80 $( " 87 $ 6" #

pI 1 80 $( " C q p r? j ba C 13 " @) 0 0 ( %4 0 H( 5 ? 4 13 2& 1 0
? ( r?

13 1` !Y iW !)

" E) hg GF C %(

%0 0 ( 4 0 H( TS fQ 1Q 2S e %4 0 ) E0 %0 0 $( 6" 6 DC '& %8 $ #"

vF C t0 0 0 $( 6" 6 uC ) #) 8 ) !) 6 Dd & $0 c" 6 A ( ) v !) %( B& A !
?

0 0 j ba 1` @( %


( 0 ) !Y XW 5

s0 td VU 9( % h

% TS RQ ( @ ?








0.100

?



B (noise bits in quantization) 2 4 6 8

B (noise bits in quantization) 2 4 6 8

?

?

( C ~ ~



0

10

0



?

?

?



?

?

?

1000

1200

1400

800

0

1

2

Simulated Data

RMS V magnitude difference (normalized by errors)

0.001

RMS position difference (pixels)

0.010

1.000

4

6 8 10 Compressed Size (bits/pixel)

WFPC2 Omega Cen

1000

1200

1400

800

0

y

y

200

400

Counts

Counts

Counts

600

-2 0

-1

200

400

600

-1

1

2

Original Mean

12

0.0001

0.0010

0.0100

0.1000

4

6 8 10 Compressed Size (bits/pixel)

1000

1200

1400

200











0

0

10 20 30 40 50 60 70

20

40

Pixel 60 80 0

0

10 20 30 40 50 60 70

20

40

Pixel 60 80 400 600 800 0

x w

WFPC2 Omega Cen

0
-1 0 1 2

B=1 Mean

10 20 30 40 50 60 70

20

40

12

10

60

80

y

W